Skip to content

Autopilot Run Report: Suggestion Re-review

Date: 2026-10-19 09:26 to 09:46 (≈20 min wall time, up to the push gate) Request: On the admin "Đề xuất" tab, an admin can move a suggestion back to Pending and review it again. In the user's History, a rejected suggestion can be sent back for re-review. Plan: plan-suggestion-rereview Skill: /autopilot (plan-autopilot). This was its first real run (QA-1 of the autopilot plan). Result: ✅ Pushed ae6366ad. Both human gates were approved, and every review passed within its round cap.

Pipeline

Stage Result Rounds
Start approved by owner (/autopilot …) —
Plan plan + TASKS section (2 Haiku explorers) 2 of 3
Plan review round 1 revise (2 blocking, 5 advisory) → round 2 approve (0 blocking, 1 advisory) 2 of 3
Gate 1 (owner) approved —
Implement 2 Sonnet builders in parallel worktrees: BE 6c16388e, FE 29c1fd94 1 of 3
Code review FE approve (0 / 4 advisory), BE approve (0 / 3 advisory) 1 of 3
Local QA ×2 scripts/qa-twice.sh: 134 tests, pass 134 · flaky 0 · fail 0 1 of 3
Fix not needed —
Land: full gates mvn verify OK (line coverage 96.72%, threshold 90%), vitest 461/461, lint 0 errors (3 old warnings) —
Gate 2 (owner) push —
CI + smoke FE + BE deploy green, mock-test.sh 22/22 —

What the plan review caught (round 1 blocking)

  1. The re-review message had no DTO validation or sanitize rule (CWE-20/79). Fix: RereviewSuggestionRequest with @Size(max=300) and @Valid, trim with blank becoming null, React renders it as text only, plus tests.
  2. Reopening an APPROVED suggestion could race with an admin retrying the import job, creating a second job or video. Fix: lock the job row (findLockedById) and re-read its status under the lock. A retry after reopen makes a later approve fail with 409 duplicateActive.

Runs (ledger)

# stage round path result blocking advisory turns min tokens model
1 plan 1 skill plan written (2 explorers) — — 50 2 102,956 Haiku 5.5
2 plan review 1 skill revise 2 5 7 1 40,591 Sonnet 5.5
3 replan 2 skill 2 blocking fixed — — — 2 (orchestrator) Opus 5.5
4 plan review 2 skill approve 0 1 6 0.3 7,898 Sonnet 5.5
5 gate 1 — — approved — — — — — owner
6 implement FE 1 skill (worktree builder) 3521a354 → 29c1fd94 — — 23 4.1 72,165 Sonnet 5.5
6b implement BE 1 skill (worktree builder) 5e2c2901 → 6c16388e — — 48 9.0 116,048 Sonnet 5.5
7 code review FE 1 skill approve 0 4 3 0.2 37,800 Sonnet 5.5
8 code review BE 1 skill approve 0 3 6 0.6 46,316 Sonnet 5.5
9 local QA ×2 1 skill pass 134 / flaky 0 / fail 0 — — — 4 (script) —
10 land: full gates — skill all green — — — 6 (orchestrator) Opus 5.5
11 gate 2 — — push — — — — — owner

All stages ran on the primary path (Skill tool); no fallback was needed. FE and BE implement ran in parallel, so their minutes overlap.

Cost

Exact figures, computed from the session transcripts with node scripts/claude-cost.mjs --from … --to … --md. The script dedupes every API request and prices it at API list price (read 2026-10-19). On a Claude subscription this is the equivalent cost, not a bill.

who model requests input cache write cache read output cost
main session (orchestrator) claude-opus-5-5 44 108 69,039 7,089,321 27,143 $2.51
worker-builder: Implement SR-FE-1 and SR-FE-2 claude-sonnet-5-5 17 34 71,105 867,056 2,483 $0.29
worker-reviewer: Code review FE re-review branch claude-sonnet-5-5 3 6 36,881 59,234 47 $0.10
worker-builder: Implement SR-BE-1 and SR-BE-2 claude-sonnet-5-5 31 62 114,353 2,065,802 756 $0.50
worker-reviewer: Review suggestion re-review plan claude-sonnet-5-5 10 26 47,720 326,676 4,678 $0.20
worker-explorer: Explore backend suggestion flow claude-haiku-5-5 8 18 47,835 258,993 6,135 $0.01
worker-reviewer: Code review BE re-review branch claude-sonnet-5-5 7 16 39,838 225,464 1,154 $0.13
worker-explorer: Explore frontend suggestion UI claude-haiku-5-5 8 16 50,974 262,587 5,835 $0.01
TOTAL 128 286 477,745 11,155,133 48,231 $3.76
  • Run total $3.76: orchestrator (Opus 5.5) $2.51 (67%), workers $1.25.
  • Cache reads dominate: 11.2M of the run's tokens are cache reads, against 48k output tokens.
  • For comparison: the run in the screenshot that inspired the skill reported $17.62.
  • Correction (2026-10-19). The first version of this report estimated the worker cost from the token totals in the Agent results. Those totals miss the repeated cache reads, so the estimate was too low. The figures above replace it.

CI and Smoke

  • ae6366ad "Deploy Frontend (React Build)": ✅ success
  • ae6366ad "Funny App Build and Deploy": ✅ success (migration 202610190001 applied on deploy)
  • ./api/mock-test.sh on prod: ✅ 22/22 (read-only; the new write endpoints are not smoke-tested by rule)

Manual Checks for the Owner (not automated)

  • SR-QA-1 on prod: reject a suggestion → the user requests re-review → the admin sees it in Pending → approve. Also reopen a rejected suggestion from the admin tab.
  • Real DB concurrency (row lock + conditional UPDATE … rereview_count < 2). The unit tests use mocks only.
  • Keyboard and screen-reader pass on the Reopen button and the re-review modal. There was no local stack to run Lighthouse.

Open Advisories (not blocking)

Area Finding
Plan Reopen erases the previous reject reason; it only survives in the audit log
FE SuggestionCard.jsx The re-review modal has no Escape key, focus trap or focus restore. Reuse the ConfirmModal pattern
FE SuggestionCard.jsx Clicking the backdrop drops the typed message
FE AdminSuggestionTable.jsx The Reopen button is not disabled while the request is pending
FE SuggestionCard.jsx REREVIEW_MAX = 2 is hardcoded. Take it from the API
BE tests Race tests use mocks only. Add a @DataJpaTest/Testcontainers test when possible
BE VideoSuggestionServiceImpl.java:269 The catch-all 404 after a 0-row update needs a comment
BE VideoImportJobRepository.java:8 Import order

Notes on the Skill (first run)

  • worker-builder uses isolation: worktree, so the implement commits landed on worktree branches. They were cherry-picked to main only after code review, which still happened before Gate 2.
  • The verdict block parsed without problems in all 4 reviews.
  • Reusing the same reviewer for plan review round 2 kept both plan-review rounds together at $0.20 (see Cost).
  • Change after this run (owner): the run report goes to docs/reports/ and the plan is not edited.