Skip to content

Autopilot Run Report: Suggestion Status Transitions (Refactor)

Date: 2026-10-19 10:34 to 10:45 (≈11 min wall time, up to the push gate) Request: Gather the suggestion status transition rules (approve, reject, reopen, rereview), now spread across the service, into one place. Behavior must not change. Plan: plan-suggestion-transitions Skill: /autopilot (second run). The skill has disable-model-invocation: true, so the owner asked in chat ("chạy autopilot refactor đó") and the orchestrator followed .claude/skills/autopilot/SKILL.md step by step. Result: ✅ Pushed 4600c1b8. Both gates were approved, every review passed in round 1, and CI plus smoke are green.

Pipeline

Stage Result Rounds
Start owner request in chat —
Plan plan + TASKS section. No explorers: the orchestrator had just read the code 1 of 3
Plan review approve (0 blocking, 4 advisory, all folded into the plan before Gate 1) 1 of 3
Gate 1 (owner) approved —
Implement 1 Sonnet builder (worktree) → f8fabaf5, cherry-picked as 08f16414. +203 / −41, 3 files 1 of 3
Code review approve (0 blocking, 2 style advisories). Behavior compared path by path: same codes, check order and lock scope 1 of 3
Local QA ×2 qa-twice.sh, 4 classes, 117 tests: pass 117 · flaky 0 · fail 0. The qa-engineer skill was skipped because every criterion already had a test 1 of 3
Fix not needed —
Land: full gates mvn verify OK, line coverage 96.71% (threshold 90%). Webapp untouched —
Gate 2 (owner) push —
CI + smoke "Funny App Build and Deploy" green, mock-test.sh 22/22 —

What changed

  • New enums/SuggestionTransition: APPROVE, REJECT, REOPEN, REREVIEW.
    • check(status, jobStatus, rereviewCount) returns a Refusal(HttpStatus, subCode, messageKey).
    • allowed(...) returns the same answer as a boolean for the DTO flags.
    • MAX_REREVIEWS and REOPENABLE_JOB_STATUSES moved into the enum.
  • VideoSuggestionServiceImpl calls the enum through refuse(Optional<Refusal>).
  • Unchanged, as the plan requires:
    • the lock order (the job row is locked only for APPROVED with an import job);
    • the order of checks (404 → transition rule → duplicate);
    • the conditional UPDATE, events and error codes 4093 / 4095 / 4096 / 4097 / 4098.
  • No existing test was edited (git diff --name-status: only 2 added files + 1 production file).

Runs (ledger)

# stage round path result blocking advisory turns min tokens model
1 plan 1 skill (orchestrator) plan written — — — 3 (orchestrator) Opus 5.5
2 plan review 1 skill approve 0 4 7 0.5 47,283 Sonnet 5.5
3 gate 1 — — approved — — — — — owner
4 implement 1 skill (worktree builder) f8fabaf5 → 08f16414 — — 16 4.6 54,130 Sonnet 5.5
5 code review 1 skill approve 0 2 5 0.4 41,141 Sonnet 5.5
6 local QA ×2 1 script (qa-engineer skipped) pass 117 / flaky 0 / fail 0 — — — 3 (script) —
7 land: full gates — skill mvn verify OK, cov 96.71% — — — 4 (orchestrator) Opus 5.5

Cost

Exact figures, computed from the session transcripts with node scripts/claude-cost.mjs --from … --to … --md. The script dedupes every API request and prices it at API list price (read 2026-10-19). On a Claude subscription this is the equivalent cost, not a bill.

who model requests input cache write cache read output cost
main session (orchestrator) claude-opus-5-5 25 56 35,570 5,602,318 18,493 $1.78
worker-reviewer: Code review transitions refactor claude-sonnet-5-5 4 8 39,959 92,168 789 $0.12
worker-builder: Implement ST-1 and ST-2 refactor claude-sonnet-5-5 12 24 53,337 434,789 2,414 $0.20
worker-reviewer: Review transitions refactor plan claude-sonnet-5-5 4 10 45,894 110,775 2,579 $0.15
TOTAL 45 98 174,760 6,240,050 24,275 $2.24
  • Run total $2.24: orchestrator (Opus 5.5) $1.78 (79%), workers $0.47.
  • Cheaper than the first run ($3.76): no explorers, one builder instead of two, and no replan round.
  • Correction (2026-10-19). The first version of this report estimated the worker cost from the token totals in the Agent results. Those totals miss the repeated cache reads, so the estimate was too low. The figures above replace it.

CI and Smoke

  • 4600c1b8 "Funny App Build and Deploy": ✅ success
  • ./api/mock-test.sh on prod: ✅ 22/22

Manual Checks for the Owner

None needed beyond CI. The change is internal and behavior is pinned by the unedited tests. An optional quick smoke on prod: reject, re-review, reopen, approve should all behave as before.

Open Advisories (not blocking)

Area Finding
SuggestionTransitionTest.java:84 Inline java.util.List. Import it
VideoSuggestionServiceImpl.java:251 The long repository.requestRereview(...) line should be wrapped

Notes on the Skill (second run)

  • Calling /autopilot from chat. The skill can't be invoked by the model, so the orchestrator ran its steps by hand after the owner asked in chat. If chat requests like this should become normal, set disable-model-invocation: false on autopilot too. Gates 1 and 2 stay mandatory either way.
  • Folding advisories before Gate 1. All four plan advisories went into the plan before Gate 1, with no extra review round. They then showed up in the code review checklist and all held.